Can You Eat Raw Oysters? The R-Month Rule, Explained
The old saying is that you should not eat oysters in a month without an “R” in it — May, June, July and August. The reasoning behind it was sound. The months without an R are the warm ones, and the coastal waters where shellfish are harvested are warmer then, which favours bacterial growth.
But the months are wrong. About 80% of Vibrio infections happen between May and October — and September and October both have an R in them. So much for that.
What the actual concern is
Vibrio is a bacterium that lives naturally in unpolluted coastal marine waters, and is more prevalent in warm water. It is not a sign of pollution; it is simply part of the environment. The illness it causes is called vibriosis.
The CDC estimates Vibrio causes around 80,000 illnesses, 500 hospitalisations and 100 deaths a year in the United States. Roughly 52,000 of those illnesses come from eating contaminated food; the rest come from exposing open wounds to brackish or salt water containing the bacteria.
In a healthy person, vibriosis usually means nausea, stomach pain, abdominal cramps, vomiting and diarrhoea, and a mild case resolves in about three days.
Who should never eat raw shellfish
This is the part that matters most, because for some people the risk is not an upset stomach — it is a severe, invasive infection.
People at highest risk should not eat raw shellfish at all:
- People with liver disease, including cirrhosis — the highest-risk group of all
- People with diabetes
- People with cancer, or who have had an organ transplant
- People with a weakened immune system for any reason
- People with stomach or blood disorders, including those taking medication that reduces stomach acid
Cooked seafood and shellfish is safe for all of these people. The restriction is on raw, not on shellfish.
Oysters specifically
Oysters are the food most commonly linked to Vibrio, because they are the one most often eaten raw. And here is the uncomfortable part: an oyster carrying harmful bacteria does not look, smell or taste any different from a safe one. There is no sorting your way out of this at the table.
- Buy from approved, inspected and regulated sources. Oysters harvested from approved waters, packed under sanitary conditions and properly refrigerated are generally safe to eat raw for healthy people.
- If you are serving them raw, they must be alive. A live oyster's shell is tightly closed, or closes when you tap it. A shell gaping open that does not close means the animal is dead and may carry high numbers of bacteria. Discard it.
- After cooking, eat only the ones that opened during cooking.
- Do not eat shucked product raw. Shellfish sold already removed from the shell is intended to be cooked.
- Wash your hands before handling raw shellfish, and keep it away from cooked food.
Cooking times that actually work
Cook in small batches, so the ones in the middle get as hot as the ones at the edge. That is the step people skip.
- Steaming: 4 to 9 minutes after the steaming starts
- Boiling: after the shells open, boil another 3 to 5 minutes
- Shucked product: boil 3 minutes, or fry at 375 °F for at least 3 minutes, or bake at 450 °F for 10 minutes
- Target: 145 °F internal temperature. A grill works too, to the same temperature.
Three things that do not work
Since we are clearing up old sayings: hot sauce does not kill Vibrio. Neither does lemon juice. Neither does drinking alcohol with your oysters. None of these has any effect on the bacteria.
A note for educators
Sea Grant's safeoysters.org makes a point worth repeating: the goal is education, not frightening people off seafood.
Seafood belongs in a healthy diet. It is an excellent source of low-fat protein and omega-3 fatty acids, with real health benefits. The message is not “avoid shellfish.” It is that eating it raw carries a risk, that the risk is small for most healthy people and serious for a few, and that everyone deserves to know which group they are in.
Cheryle Jones Syracuse, MS, Professor Emeritus, The Ohio State University
References
- Vibrio Species Causing Vibriosis, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- Safe Oysters, Sea Grant
Related reading
- Is sushi safe to eat? — the same questions, different raw food
- Getting to know listeria — the one that grows in your refrigerator
- Feeding people with food allergies — shellfish is one of the nine major allergens
- Internal cooking temperatures
Teaching materials
- Food Temperature Chart Poster — safe cooking temperatures and the danger zone
- Food Safety PowerPoint and Handouts
- Food Safety Posters
- The Food Safety collection